Laura MercierCaviar Tightline Eyeliner: Long Lasting Color, Crease-proof, Waterproof, Gel-like Hydrating Formula, Perfect for Tightline, Lash Line + Waterline

Update: cancel the retire below! I contacted the company and I was apparently trying to sharpen it incorrectly! ??? My bad ! I now am very happy with the product!Old review: “I loved the old Laura Mercier eyeliner and have used it for years. Apparently it has been phased out. I ordered this product 2 months ago. I still had some old product left and started using this new one less than a month ago. I did like the quality but it will not twist or turn to sharpen it. Even my very strong husband tried. That’s money wasted unless there is some refund or replacement.

Love this eyeliner! Goes on smoothly and is long lasting. Perfect plum color. It has not irritated my eyes since using it.

Prefect!!

This is one of the best tightliners I've used. Very smooth...no drag, and it lays down a lot pigment on 1st swipe. No, it doesn't stay on all day, but I doubt one exists that does! Pretty happy with this one!

I’ve been looking for a more precise eyeliner and this is it. Goes on very smooth in perfect lines. No smudging. I got the dark brown and will definitely be buying more colors.

Hard to sharpen. This company had a regular pencil which was great. Went on much easier. I wish companies did not change products that work well.

One of the best tight eyeliners ever used. It glides on my margins and looks natural. I am a huge fan and will purchase all colors. Need sharpener which I also purchased.

Laura Mercier quality cosmetic brand is my forever favorite, worth the price. The eye liner pencil goes on smoothly both upper and lower lids, without smearing. Regret my favorite Violet and Violet Navy color options no longer available. I was constantly complimented on my eyes and asked about the color. Having been in the business, I understand change, but will never understand replacing a best seller. The quality is always the best, but the intense Navy option didn't work for me.