McCall's Grassfed Cheddar, 12 Month Vintage

Seriously.There’s nothing too crazy about this cheese, and there’s not supposed to be:— you want great cheddar, and you’re getting it!The pics on the product description portion of the page are actually pretty legit.It says “aged,” and there’s def. a dryness to it, but it is not “dry,” per se - that’s only in comparison to, like, JUST MADE cheddar. If anything, it really helps you appreciate the flavor you already came here for.Bite it, crack it, cut it, melt it - a sufficiently determined cheesester could even *crumble* it!Says it’s grassfed, which is always a plus.I’m kinda more inclined to think they genuinely care, too, because, unlike a lot of nice cheeses, they’re using a minimal amount of recyclable plastic packaging, not some huge, fancy, multi-material display box!

I decided to make mac & cheese last minute for Thanksgiving last year. This block is the perfect amount for an 9"x13" pan of m&c. It shredded easily and was actually surprisingly creamy for a sharp cheese. The cheese sauce turned out perfectly and the dish was so perfect that I've made it several times since. This is now my go-to for homemade mac & cheese.

Good for charcuterie boards

I found it to be really delicious because of its extra sharp flavor. A little on the dryer side compared to some but, I actually really enjoyed that too. Initially purchased it on a whim as an amazon fresh weekly special at only 25¢.... yes only 25¢!! It was a great purchase. Brought it down one star only because I wouldn’t normally spend $5 on a 7oz block of cheese. But understand 25¢ Is a steal. This will definitely be a splurge item for sure... fingers crossed it comes up as a special sale item again. :)

I love the crunchiness that this cheese had. It reminds me an amazing Greek homemade aged cheese that I used to have. I wished it was a bit more aged and the final taste wasnt too buttery but it's still great!

Shreds and melts beautifully, gorgeous sharp cheddar flavor. Animal Welfare Approved convinced me to give it a try, and reading the history and ethics of this company convinced me to make it the only cheese I will buy. I wish Amazon Fresh carried their other cheeses.

This cheese was really good. It did not taste like grass. They say on the package the cow graze for 300 days out of 365 days so I am guessing it was grass feed grain finish. The sharpness of the cheese is not bad and very creamy. I will buy this again.

I wasn’t a huge fan of this cheddar. It’s good but at this price point there are others I feel are much better