Baxter Boy 6-inch Premium Grade Thick Bully Sticks Dog Treats (25 Pack) – 6” Long All Natural Gourmet Dog Treat Chews – Fresh and Savory Beef Flavor – Long Lasting Treat

I have a 71 pound Golden Retriever. He knows he's getting a favorite treat when I reach for the package.I give him one after his dinner. He goes over to where the package is and sits in front of the cabinet until I give him one of the sticks. It takes care of his need to chew and takes a while to devour. It's a quality treat, if it makes him happy I'm happy. Good stuff !

The biggest pro here is the price. It is extremely difficult to find 6'' sticks at less than $2 a stick.They are advertised as thick but that would be pretty generous, I'd say regular thickness would be fair. They aren't uniformly sized, which is to be expected nowadays but some were on the fairly really thin side, not a lot of them though.My dog is a big time chewer and these last 5-10ish minutes with her which is decent for a regular thickness stick.Unfortunately, these are not odor free but don't smell any worse than other non-odor free sticks.All in all, I've seen better, and I've seen a lot worse. You can't go wrong for the price. I'd wish the quality/thickness was a little better and I'd be happy to pay a little more.I have purchased these twice so far, so I guess you could say the first purchase was decent enough to warrant a repeat customer.

Not odor free. They smell terrible. I have had odor free bully sticks before and they did not smell.

The "odor-free" advertising is false, these smell strongly, much more than actual reduced-odor sticks like Cadet. The thickness is greatly exaggerated as well. My dog loves these sticks, so it gets a star for that, but I do not repeat business with companies willing to be as misleading as Baxter Boy has been with this product.

Not particularly thick and definitely not odor free. Besides that - they are perfectly fine bully sticks.

Bully sticks are the best treat I've found for when you need something a dog can spend a bit of time chewing. They aren't going to splinter, they aren't treated with chemicals the way rawhide is, they don't smell bad or make a mess, and I believe they're good for their teeth. They seem like a wholesome treat for a dog. I have 2 hound mixes, each about 55 lbs, for whom they are a special treat once or twice a week. They each take about 20-30 minutes to consume one. I worried that they would fight if the younger dog finished his and tried to steal from the older guy, so I started giving the young dog his bully stick in a crate. Now, all I have to do is open the bully stick container and he flies to the crate like a shot!I read a lot of reviews for the different suppliers and I chose Baxter Boy because it fit all my criteria (e.g., the 6" length, not split, a US company) and the price seemed fair. I found they are packaged well and fairly uniform in size. I'm completely satisfied and my dogs are very, very happy!

I have bought bully sticks from many companies. Baxter Boy is one of the best so far. The price is fantastic and the quality is consistent with every bag I order. My dogs love them and I finally found a brand I can stick with.Update 3/4/19: They stopped offering these through subscribe and save and the price jumped up $14. The chews are great but can't justify the price increase.

I threw them out!!!! Didn't even get my money back...smelled like a dead body. I would feed this to my worst enemy!!(yes I meant that) DO NOT BUY! wasted my money!! I definitely didn't want to replace them.