Feeder Creek Fly Box, Large 4-Sided, Waterproof and Durable for Freshwater and Saltwater Fly Fishing Lures, 524 Split Foam Fly Slots and Swing Leaf Insert (6" X 4" X 1 3/4")

1.) New Phase Salmon Fly Box. The best of the five.The winner. Best latch opens easily and closes securely. Lid stays parallel when not supported, doesn't flop down making items potentially fall out. Easy one-handed opening and closing.2.) Aventik 100% Waterproof Swing Leaf Fly Box. Looks almost identical to number one yet has a significant flaw- the lid flops down when opened so things potentially will roll out of it if not on a flat surface. Also the latch is much more awkward to open one-handed than the New Phase.3.) Hicreat Double-Sides Fishing Tackle Box. Very sturdy! But flaws are that the latch is ridiculously complicated, unfolds like a transformer and is difficult to operate one-handed. Not intuitive! Also, the interior wastes a lot of space.4.) Feeder Creek Fly Fishing Fly Box. No major flaws but most expensive. Nice box.5.) Kingfisher XL Lightweight Foam fly Box. Don't waste your money. The "hinge" is nothing but a thin piece of flimsy fabric which I would estimate will fail after one full day of use in the outdoors. Looks like a make-up case rebranded as a fly box. The magnetic closure is cool though.

So happy with this purchase. The foam is durable and sturdy. The spacing is perfect. You have to skip a slot for bigger flies, it lays really nicely. Totally waterproof as far as I could tell. Way better design than my previous box. Opens and closes without a problem.

Nice durable looking Fly box and will hold more smaller trout flies then you should ever need to carry on one fishing trip.

No dislikes! Holds tons of flus!

Tons of room for your flys. Only box I carry.

Excellent I was able to combine 3 fly boxes into this one

NOT WATER PROOF.

On my last fishing trip I didn't realize that the "durable ABS plastic" had a small crack and water flooded my flies. i later found the hooks all rusted. Is it possible for you to send me a replacement?