Too FacedKiller Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil | Long Lasting + Smudge Proof, 0.04 oz.

I love, love this color...it matches perfectly with my hair/brown eyes. At first I was so dissapointed because it's a plasticky point that looks like you can't sharpen. When I figured it out and did, nothing but wooden shards. I had to keep constantly sharpening, therefore wasting most of it. Twice, after I bought a second. However, I saw reviews on here about a German sharpener. A lot of people recommended that type. Whooa a game changer. Now I can sharpen and it's a perfect amount of product in a point!! So I'm a happy camper now!

Very pigmented and it stays on pretty well. I do have oily skin so it does smear a little bit but compared to other eyeliners such as regular drugstore brands which were supposedly able to stay on, this does so pretty well. Line quality is smooth. I haven’t had much issues breaking. When I do need to remove it I do suggest using a makeup remover bc it is pretty waterproof. I think it was worth the cost.

Eyeliner is a critical part of my beauty routine. I often don’t wear shadow at all, just winged liner. So I’m very good at judging liner quality. Having mature skin further complicates my “perfect eyeliner” quest. I prefer the soft, gentle glide of potted gel liners. However, I find that it’s more difficult to apply a winged, sleek line with a brush. When I discovered that “Too Faced” now makes eyeliner, I knew it had to be good. This glassy slick gel pencil glides on beautifully AND lasts up to 36 hrs. I love it!!! I have removed this liner with a bit of Clinique brand “Take the Day Off” and a make up wipe (Neutrogena). In a pinch, just a wipe will suffice, tho it does tug a bit. Rich pigments tattoo your eyes with color and beautiful wings. Once easily applied, it must be removed. My tecnnique is great, but you don’t need anything special; just a steady hand. Colors are so good!! Deep, silky brown and midnight inky black. It’s always perfect and stays put until you take it off!

Not my favorite. The color is fine and it sharpens well, but it always runs down my eyes. Many reviews says it lasts, but I don’t have that same experience. It’s certainly easy to remove with make-up wipes, but I likely wouldn’t purchase again.

Hands down the best eyeliner!! Lasts forever. Just wish it wasn’t a pencil you had to sharpen.

Perfect color of dark brown I was looking for . Goes on easy . It smudges some thru out the day only thing I don’t like about it .

I love this eye liner, but it is over priced.

Liner seemed old. It was super dry and a battle to apply. The pencil inside was loose so when sharpened the tip would just break off and fall out. Not my favorite purchase.