Bella 1.5 QT Ice Cream Maker - Orange

I bought this machine at Goodwill for my ice cream eating monsters. I see why it was donated to the thrift store. It SUCKS. First time I made ice cream it was soupy so after reading the reviews and taking suggestions, I made a second batch. No luck. We still have ice soup. Super bummed. If you see this in stores or at the thrift stores, leave it. Run. Run in the other direction!

I bought one of these at Sam's Club because it had a rebate. It worked great, even when you added in fruit or other things into the ice cream. I am giving it 3 stars because the churning paddle broke while I was moving and I haven't been able to find a replacement for it. The paddle broke too easily for my liking and it is too hard to find a replacement for it. Now the thing just sits on the shelf because I can't bring myself to throw it out just yet.

I made a custard-based ice cream, preparing the base the night before, so it could refrigerate and be nice and cold already before putting it in the ice cream maker. The next evening, I took the base out of the fridge, the tub out of the freezer, assembled the machine, turned it on, then poured the base into the top per the instructions. Within just ten minutes, it had frozen/thickened to the consistency of soft serve ice cream. I then poured the ice cream into a plastic bowl, put the lid on, then put it in the freezer for a couple of hours to firm up even more (though, we could've eaten it as soon as it froze to soft-serve thickness and been perfectly happy with it).The motor was much louder than I expected, but beyond this, everything worked great. I see others have had issues with theirs, but I imagine it's a combination of factors they're facing. Perhaps their freezers aren't set to their coldest temperatures (closer to 0 degrees, rather than 10 to 15 degrees...this makes a HUGE difference, believe it or not) or they didn't use pre-mixed base that they had chilled first (mixing ingredients after taking them out of the fridge will let them warm up very quickly). I think with a combination of a really coldly frozen tub and thoroughly chilled base, they'd have a similar experience to mine.So far, I like it. As long as the motor lasts, the mixing paddle doesn't break, etc., for $10 ($20 purchase price at Sam's, plus a $10 mail-in rebate), I'm quite pleased with it. Yes, I'd take the Cuisinart Pure Indulgence over this one, but it's upwards of $90, which makes making your own ice cream an incredibly expensive endeavor. This Bella ice cream maker does just fine, and for much, much less money.Update: I just tried the recipe for coconut ice cream from Williams-Sonoma's website, and it's incredible. It's possibly the best ice cream I've ever eaten. And, as it has with all the other batches of ice cream I've made, this ice cream maker performed great.

The product I order was just as I thought it would be. It also did the job just as it should have.

Fake it til you make it? This thing couldn't even make it past the "fake."We followed each direction, freezing the bowl for +24hrs, washing everything, preparing our ice cream mixture ahead of time and chilling it in the fridge.When it came time to actually make the ice cream, we fully assembled the unit, poured in the cooled liquid mixture and turned the dial to "On."Within a quarter turn (the tub turns, not the plastic churning blade), the churner snapped. Considering that the churning needs to happen as the liquid cools and freezes, our ice cream maker was now useless.We now have a kitchen appliance about the size of a small toaster oven that cannot be repaired or used.Also, we still do not have ice cream.

I think the reviewers who only ended up with soup may not have cooled their mixtures long enough. I have used the ice cream maker twice, and have come up with soft serve both times. Once, I cooled the base mixture in the fridge over night, and the other time, I cooled the mixture in the fridge for a few hours and took it out just as the sides of the bowl started freezing.After making the ice cream in the machine, we simply put the ice cream in the freezer to harden more. Not a bad little machine. The motor is loud. I didn't realize how loud until I had walked up stairs and realized I could still hear it clearly. And with how long everything takes to cool, you do have to plan ahead.We got our machine for $19 at Sam's with a $10 mail-in-rebate (so $9). So, I love the little thing for the price we got it. But if your paying full price, you'll probably want to look for another option.